Synopsis
Takeo's world is upended when his entire family is killed and his village is obliterated. He is adopted by his mysterious savior and learns he is a member of the Tribe, a family of assassins that possesses modest supernatural powers. He hones his skills and nurses dreams of revenge.
My take
I can't remember how I first heard about this book—I may have read about it when it the New York Times named it one of the notable books of the year in 2002—but I'm glad I put it on my reading list.
The story takes place in a world that's very similar—but obviously not identical—to feudal Japan. While some of the characters and events are based on real historical figures and occurrences, I didn't mind that they weren't exact copies. Lian Hearn introduced the concept of a separate race of people who can move at super speeds and make themselves invisible, so why not alter other details to suit the story?
Across the Nightingale Floor was written for a non-Japanese audience, so I was impressed at how seamlessly Hearn incorporated information about a history and culture that most readers probably wouldn't know much about. Her writing style also helps move the story along smoothly.
Takeo has a strong voice and is a well-drawn character. I felt for him and was fully invested in his part of the story. It was fun to read along as he discovered his new talents, and it was wrenching to read about the choices he faced—avenge his family, stay loyal to his adoptive father, or fully join the Tribe. His metamorphosis from country boy to mature warrior is well done. Unfortunately, the female lead, Kaede, does not fare so well. Her story is never as captivating or convincing as Takeo's. She's supposed to be a young woman who finds strength within herself much as Takeo does, but it seems forced and even a little cliched. Takeo's and Kaede's stories eventually mesh and they predictably fall in love immediately. It was sweet to read about but distracted from the larger picture. The narrative was strong—until the end, which was mostly Kaede's fault. Without giving too much away, I understand she needed revenge just like Takeo did, but the resolution to her story seemed contrived and it came at the expense of a satisfying conclusion for Takeo. Since he was the main protagonist, I felt cheated.
Bottom line
Highly enjoyable and mostly terrific. I'd recommend it, especially if you have any interest in feudal Japan. It's the first book in a series—I put the second one on my to-read list, but I didn't run out and get it, mostly because I was a little disappointed in the ending.
Fine print
Across the Nightingale Floor, by Lian Hearn
Genre: Fantasyish/historyish fiction
Photo from Goodreads
I borrowed this book from the library
Showing posts with label historical fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label historical fiction. Show all posts
Monday, April 9, 2012
Tuesday, October 25, 2011
The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle
Synopsis
Charlotte Doyle sails from England to Rhode Island sans adult supervision. Adventure ensues.
My thoughts
"A truly great book should be read in youth, again in maturity, and once more in old age, as a fine building should be seen by morning light, at noon, and by moonlight."—Robertson Davies
My youth is over, so I'm working with a limited number of books here, but I've noticed remarkable differences in the books I've reread as an adult. When I first read Charlotte Doyle as an elementary schooler, I loved the historical setting and the strong character Charlotte became over the course of the book. Nearly 20 years later, that was about all I could remember. The details had completely escaped me.
As it turns out, Charlotte's growth from sheltered little miss to self-confident young woman is the most powerful part of the book, and I'm not surprised it resonated with my eleven-year-old self. This time around, I was struck by how well-researched the book is and how deftly Avi shares historical details and nautical expertise without pausing the action or being condescending. That alone would have made the book worth it, but the engrossing plot elevates it even further.
Charlotte Doyle was the Newbery Honor Book for 1991, and it richly deserved that award. I'd be curious to reread Jerry Spinelli's Maniac Magee, which won the top honor that year, because I remember loving that book too.
Bottom line
A truly great read in both youth and maturity. I'm willing to predict it will hold up for old age too.
Fine print
The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle, by Avi
Genre: Young adult historical fiction
Photo from Goodreads
I bought this book.
First read in 1992; reread October 2011
Charlotte Doyle sails from England to Rhode Island sans adult supervision. Adventure ensues.
My thoughts
"A truly great book should be read in youth, again in maturity, and once more in old age, as a fine building should be seen by morning light, at noon, and by moonlight."—Robertson Davies
My youth is over, so I'm working with a limited number of books here, but I've noticed remarkable differences in the books I've reread as an adult. When I first read Charlotte Doyle as an elementary schooler, I loved the historical setting and the strong character Charlotte became over the course of the book. Nearly 20 years later, that was about all I could remember. The details had completely escaped me.
As it turns out, Charlotte's growth from sheltered little miss to self-confident young woman is the most powerful part of the book, and I'm not surprised it resonated with my eleven-year-old self. This time around, I was struck by how well-researched the book is and how deftly Avi shares historical details and nautical expertise without pausing the action or being condescending. That alone would have made the book worth it, but the engrossing plot elevates it even further.
Charlotte Doyle was the Newbery Honor Book for 1991, and it richly deserved that award. I'd be curious to reread Jerry Spinelli's Maniac Magee, which won the top honor that year, because I remember loving that book too.
Bottom line
A truly great read in both youth and maturity. I'm willing to predict it will hold up for old age too.
Fine print
The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle, by Avi
Genre: Young adult historical fiction
Photo from Goodreads
I bought this book.
First read in 1992; reread October 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)